March 13, 2024
It’s beginning to look a lot like Christmas under the Gold Dome. December 25 may be nine months away, but Christmas trees are appearing everywhere. The most prominent bill so far passed out of the House Education Committee on Wednesday. SB 233, the "Georgia Promise Scholarship Act," returned as what Speaker Pro Tem Jan Jones (R-Milton) termed an "omnibus education bill." The measure still has a new voucher program, but it also adds in language from HB 941 and HB 1221 (which did not make it out of the House this spring) and two other legislative provisions just now seeing the light of day. Whether the additions actually improve the bill’s prospects is yet to be seen, but we’re watching committees closely for more fun and games as adjournment sine die approaches. Watch along with us in this #GoldDomeReport.
The House took up the following measures on Legislative Day 34:
The Senate took up the following measures on Legislative Day 34:
House Education Committee
The House Education Committee, chaired by Representative Chris Erwin (R-Homer), met on Wednesday to consider two measures.
Before the committee took up business, Chairman Erwin recognized Speaker Jon Burns (R-Newington) to offer some remarks. The speaker, acknowledging this was his first Education Meeting to attend, explained that he is “thoroughly convinced” SB 233 can make a difference in this state. He thanked his House colleagues who voted for the bill last year, as well as the 16 House Republicans who voted no and agreed to dialogue with leaders to improve the bill. Speaker Burns highlighted a few of the additions to the substitute bill to be presented to the committee, including codifying teacher pay raises and capital funding for pre-K classrooms.
Speaker Pro Tem Jan Jones (R-Milton) presented the substitute (LC 33 9709S) to the committee, beginning by highlighting all the ways the state already pays toward tuition for Georgia students attending certain private schools and colleges. The substitute includes several changes from the original version of the bill, including establishing a Georgia Education Savings Authority under the Georgia Student Finance Commission to administer the new voucher program. Speaker Jones explained that the core of the voucher program remains essentially the same, including the same amount of $6,500 per student per year, priority for students from families making less than 400% of the federal poverty level, and eligibility limited to students from schools in the bottom 25% in performance. She indicated that she also added a funding cap that will limit funding to 1% of annual QBE appropriation and a sunset after 10 years (with grandfathering for students participating at the time of sunset).
Speaker Jones called the substitute an “omnibus education bill”, as it also includes a codification of Governor Brian Kemp’s teacher pay raises in the statutory QBE formula and provision for the use of capital funds to build pre-K classrooms from HB 941. The substitute also includes “public school choice” as proposed in HB 1221, with a limit on tuition that can be charged by receiving school districts. Finally, the substitute triples the existing public school tax credit from $5 million to $15 million and designates that $10 million of funds be reserved for schools at the lowest 25% of performance.
Representative Scott Hilton (R-Peachtree Corners) posed a series of leading questions to reiterate the state’s full funding of the QBE formula over six of the last seven years and comment on the General Assembly’s “dedication to public schools and public school funding.” Representative Mesha Mainor (R-Atlanta) highlighted the increases to the statutory QBE formula weights for special education and ESOL students. Representative Will Wade (R-Dawsonville) emphasized the support for all education, including public schools, in the bill and limits on funding to 1% of QBE allocations. He also highlighted the “accountability measures” included on page 18 of the bill. Representative Becky Evans (D-Atlanta) asked whether the existing teacher pay raises depend on the amendment to the QBE weights and confirmed that there will be some students who are eligible for the voucher without ever attending a public school (particularly 4-year-olds who matriculate into the program). Representative Lydia Glaize (D-Fairburn) proposed an amendment that would require private schools receiving public funds to admit any student who applies, which Speaker Pro Tem Jones said she would not support.
Representative Hilton moved that the bill DO PASS, and Representative Glaize offered her proposed amendment, which was rejected. Representative Doreen Carter (D-Lithonia) offered an amendment that any participating private school employ only certified teachers, which was rejected.
The committee recommended the bill DO PASS by a 13-7 vote and be sent to the Rules Committee.
House Education Committee - Curriculum Subcommittee
The Curriculum Subcommittee of the House Education Committee, chaired by Representative Bethany Ballard (R-Warner Robins), met on Tuesday to consider one measure:
Senator Billy Hickman (R-Statesboro) presented the bill to the subcommittee as a substitute (LC 50 0845S), particularly focusing on the universal screener requirement he promoted for inclusion in the Senate. Senator Hickman said that the Deal Center has already graded existing literacy screeners, and it does not make sense for the Department of Education to develop its own. The substitute presented to the subcommittee changes the single universal screener provision to a requirement that the department identify a list of five screeners, one of which must be free, no later than May 15, 2024. Each school district may then choose from the five identified screeners.
Claire Buck of the Georgia Association of Curriculum and Instructional Supervisors spoke on the bill, explaining that many districts have spent substantial time and effort on selecting a universal screener and called for local control. Josh Stephens of the Professional Association of Georgia Educators expressed support for the underlying School Supplies for Teachers Program and highlighted that their member survey shows support for HB 538 and its implementation as passed. Steve Tippins, representing Class Wallet, spoke in favor of the bill. Matt Cardoza of the Georgia Department of Education spoke and noted that its vendor, DRC, creates the Georgia Milestones exams and has already conducted thousands of field tests of the screener it developed and has trainings planned for the summer to allow August implementation. Scott Johnson of the Georgia Literacy Council spoke and said that we need an established, proven literacy screener now.
Representative Doreen Carter (D-Lithonia) moved to strike all language in the substitute relating to the literacy screeners, but the motion failed. The subcommittee recommended the bill DO PASS by Substitute and be sent to the full Education Committee.
House Education Committee - Policy Subcommittee
The Policy Subcommittee of the House Education Committee, chaired by Representative Scott Hilton (R-Peachtree Corners), met on Tuesday to consider one measure:
Representative Scott Hilton (R-Peachtree Corners) presented the bill to the subcommittee as a substitute (LC 49 1867S) and proposed amendments in recognition of conversations that the author had with the Georgia Emergency Management and Homeland Security Agency. The amendments provide an additional year for implementation and require that mobile panic alert systems integrate with existing 911 technology infrastructure. GEMA appeared and confirmed support for the bill with the proposed amendments.
Representative Will Wade (R-Dawsonville) offered the proposed amendments, which were adopted. The subcommittee recommended the bill DO PASS by substitute as amended and be sent to the full Education Committee.
House Juvenile Justice Committee
The House Juvenile Justice Committee, chaired by Representative Mandi Ballinger (R-Canton), met on Tuesday to consider the following:
Representative Rhonda Taylor (D-Conyers) asked about the definition of substantial progress. Senator Tillery explained it was more than what was being done right now. Representative David Wilkerson (D-Powder Springs) asked about lines 56 and 57; there was an initial review and subsequent review and they clarified that the bill moves substantial progress up. Senator Tillery explained that the goal is to ensure that parents are not just meeting one at a time. Representative Wilkerson further asked that they are moving the benchmark which Senator Tillery agreed with.
Troup County Juvenile Court Judge Michael Key expressed support for the measure and discussed the statutory time frames with each case with regard to the plans.
The measure received a DO PASS recommendation and will be carried out by Representative Joseph Gullett (R-Dallas).
Representative Dar'shun Kendrick (D-Lithonia) asked about a date in the bill. An amendment will be required to update the date she highlighted. Representative Jodi Lott (R-Evans) asked about the number of foster homes. There are somewhere between 10,000-12,000 homes. Chairlady Ballinger asked if the author would be amenable to removing certification. Senator Brass explained he wanted some level of certification but was amenable to lessening the burden.
An amendment was offered to change the dates to 2024 in lines 160 and 176. The measure received a DO PASS recommendation as amended. Representative Marcus Wiedower (R-Watkinsville) will carry the measure.
Representative Esther Panitch (D-Sandy Springs) asked if these were monthly numbers and if parenting time deviation would still require an explanation. These are monthly numbers. With the deviation, it has to be specifically requested and it is under a judge's discretion. The state is seeing more 50/50 parenting time. There would not be specific findings of fact for the adjustment. Representative Panitch followed up asking if the earlier numbers were reduced and inquired about the cost in the new table. The new table is developed by an expert economist. At $5,400 and below, the table does reduce support slightly. At that point and above, it increases significantly. These are purely economic recommendations. Representative Joseph Gullett (R-Dallas) asked if someone is on 100% disability, how it played into child support, and if they are not a veteran but are on social security. Is there anything non-disability-wise that goes into the calculation? They were not aware. Representative Gullett asked about enforcement and collection. The measure does not address those. Representative Jodi Lott (R-Evans) asked how gross income is calculated with inflation. The economists have determined the calculation is best handled at the gross level. There are adjustments made for self-employment and other things.
General Council at the Department of Human Services Regina Quick provided more context to some of the questions that were asked. She also highlighted a need to make a few amendments relating to arrears and lump sum payments citing cases. Those were in lines 511 and 536 by changing "shall not" to "may" and also in lines 512 and 537 by adding child support amount. This was a policy discussion the committee debated. Senator Strickland explained he knew of the concern from his conversations with the commission but this had not been raised in the Senate and it was the first time he was hearing of it in regard to this bill. He understood that it was a decision the committee could make.
Chairlady Ballinger proposed amendment one on line 511 striking “shall not” and inserting “may.” This amendment failed. She also proposed amendment two on line 513 by adding after arrears “final child support amount.” This amendment failed. The chair offered amendment three on line 536 replacing “shall not” with “may.” This amendment failed because there was no motion. Finally, amendment four on line 538 adding after arrears “final child support amount” was proposed by Chairlady Ballinger. This amendment failed. The measure received a DO PASS recommendation and will be carried by Representative Houston Gaines (R-Athens).
Senate Insurance and Labor Committee
The committee, chaired by Senator Larry Walker (R-Perry) voted out five bills Wednesday afternoon.
First, it passed HB 984, by Representative Eddie Lumsden (R-Armuchee). This will allow the use of police vehicles by off duty officers, in certain circumstances, and provide for insurance for that purpose. It also provided that individual and group health could include dependents, who were disabled past the age of 18.
The committee then passed HB 1049, by Representative Bruce Williamson (R-Monroe), to permit insurance companies to transfer parts of their books of business to other insurers, when a company is insolvent.
Next, the committee passed HB 1125 brought by Representative Sharon Cooper (R-Marietta) which raised the wages paid by sheltered workshops for disabled citizens. These are being phased out in favor of placing disabled persons in regular employment, but the bill allowed a larger wage to be paid for the remaining sheltered workshops.
The committee next turned to the Back the Blue Fund, HB 935, brought by Representative Ken Vance (R-Milledgeville) which allows donations to be made to sheriffs for bonuses to law enforcement personnel when the person buys a license plate.
Finally, the committee passed the governor's tort reform bill, HB 1114. The measure authorizes the Insurance Commissioner to collect data from tort insurance companies about judgments they have paid and analyze the data. The thought is that this state of collection can precede additional tort reforms. Some skepticism was raised about the ability of an insurer to report the information required by the bill, but it passed five to one.
House Regulated Industries - Regulatory Subcommittee
The Regulatory Subcommittee, chaired by Representative Ginny Ehrhart (R-Marietta), was called to order Tuesday to discuss the following:
John Simpson from Newsmax Media and Taylor Hawkins from Frontline Policy Action expressed support for the measure.
The substitute received a DO PASS recommendation with one in opposition.
Senate Children and Families Committee
Chairman Kay Kirkpatrick (R-Marietta) and the Children and Families Committee met on Tuesday, taking up only one bill:
House Ways and Means Committee
Chairman Shaw Blackmon (R-Bonaire) called the House Committee to order Tuesday to discuss the following:
House Public Safety & Homeland Security Committee - Dean Greene Subcommittee
The Dean Greene Subcommittee of the House Public Safety & Homeland Security Committee, chaired by Representative Gerald Greene (R-Cuthbert), met on Tuesday to consider one measure:
Representative Rick Townsend (R-Brunswick) presented the bill to the Subcommittee, and Alex Carnie with CRG Solutions provided testimony as a potential vendor. Representative Bill Werkheiser (R-Glennville) asked whether school safety funding provided by the state could be used to finance this mapping, to which Representative Townsend said yes. Representative Clint Crowe (R-Jackson) asked about the accessibility and security of these maps. Representative Ken Vance (R-Milledgeville) asked how these maps would differ from those previously required, to which Carnie explained key operational elements that these maps would have that were not previously required. In response to a question from Representative Jodi Lott (R-Evans), Carnie explained that the cost for mapping is approximately $4,000 per school. Representative Townsend reiterated that there are multiple vendors who can provide these mapping services.
Chris Stallings, Director of the Georgia Emergency Management and Homeland Security Agency, spoke to the bill, explaining that GEMA is most interested in ensuring that mapping and other emergency response materials are accessible and usable by first responders of varying levels of sophistication.
Chairman Greene asked that Representatives Crowe and Vance work with Representative Townsend to address the data security concerns so that the subcommittee can vote on a clean bill. No further action was taken on the bill.
House Higher Education Committee
Chairman Chuck Martin (R-Alpharetta) and members of the House Higher Education Committee took up the following measures on Wednesday afternoon:
“encourage and state expectations for the Board of Regents of the University System of Georgia, units of the University System of Georgia, and local boards of education to enter into and amend existing agreements with the State Board of the Technical College System of Georgia and units of the Technical College System of Georgia for awarding postsecondary course credits that are transferable between the university system and the technical college system and between units thereof.”
The legislation received no changes and received a DO PASS recommendation. Representative Matt Dubnik (R-Gainesville) will carry the bill in the House.
Senate Regulated Industries Committee
Chairman Bill Cowsert (R-Athens) and members of the Senate Regulated Industries Committee took up the following bills on Tuesday afternoon:
The following bills were “HEARING ONLY”:
Neil Herring of the Sierra Club expressed concern over the measure.
Mark Swartz the Georgia Association of Acupuncture and Asian Medicine expressed concern with this measure and explained this began in 2011 and in 2016 the American Medical Association reported acupuncture and dry needling are indistinguishable. A medical doctor in Georgia who wants to practice has to take a 300-hour class. An individual who wants to be licensed can go take a weekend class to become licensed for the upper body. Azure Duan from the Chinese Acupuncture Alliance of Georgia expressed concern and noted that Georgia has stricter laws including postgraduate supervision with additional criteria.
An occupational therapist came forward and explained their degree requirements. Chairman Cowsert asked how their training worked. It requires a graduate degree plus the extra 26 hours for dry needling. Tom Bauer with the Georgia Occupational Therapy Association provided additional context and expressed support for the measure. Chairman Cowsert asked about the difference between occupational and physical therapists. Occupational therapists are trying to return people to work and to perform a specific function.
Representative Powell explained occupational therapists are not claiming to be acupuncturists. Senator Ed Harbison (D-Columbus) asked about the 26 hours and if OTs would reduce their requirement to becoming an acupuncturist. Representative Powell did not think an OT would be taking this course to become an acupuncturist but to add to their toolbox. Physical therapists are allowed to do dry needling now. Representative Powell explained no doctors in the House raised concern.
Senate Health and Human Services Committee
Chairman Ben Watson (R-Savannah) and the Senate Health and Human Services Committee met on Wednesday afternoon, hijacking some bills for proposals that had otherwise not moved through the process:
The following new legislation of interest has been introduced in the House:
H.R.1416 |
House Study Committee on Felony Sentencing and Punishment in Georgia; create |
Rep. Yasmin Neal (D-079) |
|
H.R.1418 |
House Study Committee on the Use of Local Fees to Support Affordable Housing; create |
Rep. Phil "Phillip" Olaleye (D-059) |
|
H.R.1433 |
House Study Committee on the Eradication of Homelessness; create |
Rep. Eric Bell (D-075) |
The following new legislation of interest has been introduced in the Senate:
S.R.770 |
Senate Higher Education in Prison Study Committee; create |
Sen. Sally Harrell (D-040) |
The General Assembly will reconvene for Legislative Day 35 on Thursday, March 14 at 10 a.m.
The House is expected to take up the following measures on Legislative Day 35:
The Senate is expected to take up the following measures on Legislative Day 35:
These materials have been prepared for informational purposes only and are not legal advice. This information is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. Internet subscribers and online readers should not act upon this information without seeking professional counsel.