Skip to Main Content

The Vault

Large circular vault door partially open with light shining through

Oct. 5, 2023

Build or Buy: New Observations Regarding a Key Choice for How to Start a “New” Bank

By Benjamin A. Barnhill, Neil E. Grayson, J. Brennan Ryan, Robert Klingler, Mark L. Miller

This is the third installment of our series evaluating the choice between starting a “new” bank through the de novo chartering process or purchasing an existing bank to implement the new business plan. Since we first wrote on this topic, we have been fortunate to assist a number of clients in forming both de novo and de facto de novo banks, including even during the turbulent financial markets in 2023. The recent economic downturn, partially caused by the Federal Reserve’s efforts to combat inflation, has noticeably slowed de novo bank organizational efforts. The depressed stock prices for banks and the high-profile failures of several banks in 2023 have also curtailed the interest of both prospective organizers and investors in pursuing new banks. In addition, in our experience, the supportive attitude of the FDIC to de novo banks under former Chairwoman Jelena McWilliams has been supplanted by a less favorable attitude and more prolonged reviews from the agency under current Chairman Martin Gruenberg. Nevertheless, we believe there continue to be significant opportunities to pursue, particularly with de facto de novo banks, as banks acquired in challenging environments can present huge opportunities to investors or acquirers.

Read the full article.